In the 1990s, the Schmidt family duked it out, and in the end, one side got to keep the name Kreuz Market, while the other side got to keep the original building from 1900. Happily, everyone continued to make top-notch barbecue. Perhaps the loss of the Kreuz name and reputation has kept the crew at Smitty’s working extra hard to maintain quality. Whatever it is, it’s working.
The old red brick building near the town square hasn’t changed a bit, and the heat from the fire that is right there—watch your children, please—can be heaven or hell, depending on the season. We take visitors here for the 100%-Texas experience. Within these greasy, smoked-black walls, you can watch men with giant metal hooks wrestle your meat out of the pit.
The dining room is bright and plain, in stark contrast to the more done-up Kreuz Market. We hate paying for beans and pickles, especially when the former are this bland, but we can hardly fault the ’cue. Smoke-ringed brisket can come rather dry; order it fatty or from the end to combat this. We’ve had incredible prime rib: rare, smoky, juicy, full-flavored beef loveliness. Ribs are on the sweeter side, but tender when you get a meaty one. The best work, though, is loose-packed sausage, which squirts intensely flavorful juice when bitten into. We don’t even mind getting hit with it.
Get the 592-page book—it’s an indispensable reference and a great gift—available online or at an Austin-area store.
Or, subscribe to fearlesscritic.com for just $10 per year—the price of a martini—or try it out for $2 per month. You’ll get access to the complete Fearless Critic content online, including more than 1,000 reviews from all Fearless Critic cities, new reviews as they’re written throughout the year, and advanced search features.
If you’re already a subscriber, please login to your account.
Top Barbecue in Austin
9.5 Franklin Barbecue9.4 Louie Mueller BBQ
9.3 Snow’s Bar-B-Q
9.0 City Market
8.9 Cooper’s
8.9 Ray’s BBQ
8.9 Kreuz Market
8.8 Smitty’s Market
8.6 City Meat Market
8.2 Danny’s BBQ
Newest Austin reviews
- Franklin Barbecue
- El Naranjo
- Haddington’s
- Teji’s Foods
- Foreign & Domestic
- Taco More
- Barley Swine
- Uchiko
- G’Raj Mahal
- Congress
Most delicious in Austin
9.7 Congress9.7 Uchiko
9.6 Uchi
9.5 Franklin Barbecue
9.4 Louie Mueller BBQ
9.3 Snow’s Bar-B-Q
9.3 Teji’s Foods
9.3 Taco More
9.2 Justine’s Brasserie
9.2 Olivia









Wanted to go here for my birthday since it had such a good review.
Brisket was pretty dry (and I asked for center/fatty). If it wasn't for the hot sauce on the table, it may have not been edible.
Prime Rib was ok at best. First off, I asked for rare, and the rarest they had was medium. The outside had good flavor, but the inside was dry and flavorless.
Their prime rib and brisket was a dime a dozen, imo.
The best I had there was their hot rings (sausage). This was actually fantastic.
However, I am not a big sausage eater. I usually like a couple of bites when I go out for bbq. I would not return just for the sausage.
I'd probably rank the food a 6.0. Only that high because of the sausage.
Barbecue continues to be one of the most frustratingly inconsistent things to review, but we take the average of several visits. Out of curiosity, what's your favorite brisket in Central TX?
The fatty brisket was pretty dry, although the fat was just wonderful. I was disappointed, but that doesn't mean I still didn't enjoy every bite. I did. As long as I got fat in the bite there was plenty of juice and flavor. Ribs were my favorite. Loose-packed sausage is much preferable to the solid stuff.
With a bottle of Big Red and a $1 cone of Blue Bell, it was a Saturday well spent.