Fearless Critic
Brutally honest reviews. Undercover chefs and food nerds. No restaurant sponsors.
Fearless Critic restaurant review
Food
6.7
Feel
8.0
Price
$50
Piranha Killer Sushi
A chic downtown space where the sexed-up sushi and drinks barely pass muster
Japanese
Upmarket restaurant

Hours
Mon–Wed 11:00am–10:00pm
Thu 11:00am–11:00pm
Fri 11:00am–midnight
Sat noon–midnight
Sun noon–10:00pm

Features Date-friendly, Wi-Fi
Bar Beer, wine, liquor
Credit cards Visa, MC, AmEx
Reservations Accepted

Website

Convention Center
207 San Jacinto Blvd.
Austin, TX
(512) 473-8775

If the SoCal-ish name doesn’t deter you (the small chain is based up in Arlington), then you might find yourself in this attractive converted warehouse space, where streams of ambient light fill the open dining area by day, bringing a soft glow to expanses of blond wood. At night, thumping music and mood lighting readies dates for saketini-fueled make-out sessions. Chic, molded Eames chairs are tucked up around tables and booths, jockeying for floor space with the padded stools around a central rectangular sushi bar. Hot tea is served, pleasantly, in glazed ceramic, and wine and sake bottles peek out from a wall rack of dramatic scale.

Given the lush interior, one could suppose that Piranha ran out of money before it got around to sourcing its fish, which tends to be bland and mushy, with the sinewy strands of roughly cut flesh that perhaps wasn’t up to the task in the first place. The thawed-out taste of the sashimi isn’t really improved by its presentation in cute bento boxes, or by the occasional shiso leaf. More attention seems to be given to the accompanying salads, like one with hearts of palm and cucumber.

Piranha does a better job when hiding its so-so fish inside of specialty rolls. While none of it is traditional maki, some will appreciate the forearm-sized servings teeming with fried shrimp, cream cheese, and fancy mayonnaises. A few intriguing creations certainly attract attention, like tuna, avocado, and strawberry in a “Marry Me” roll; and crawfish, mango, and ginger in a “Sexy” roll. But these flavor combinations are as unconvincing and desperate as their names. The rolls amount to tempura-fried American picnic salads, some of which even taste pretty good, but hardly qualify for a rating within Japanese cuisine.

If the eponymous grub is flubbed, you’re bound to have less success with ambitious cross-Asian dishes like pad Thai with udon noodles and Korean grilled steak. (Was it grilled by Koreans? Served in a “Korean” sauce? Sliced from a Korean cow? Give us a break.) Teriyaki, yakitori, and tempura make this place simply a much hipper Wiki Wiki.

Salvage a shred of dignity by sticking with the sake selection, although its range is pretty limited. With a cocktail menu consisting of not-too-sweet, sweet, and downright-dessert drinks, and sporting options like the “Wedding Cake,” the “Naughty Asian,” and the “Sexytini,” you’re left wondering which ’90s sorority was hired to consult.

Piranha are less known for their succulent flesh than for their mindless, efficient annihilation of anything of substance. In that sense, this place—sexy as it is—couldn’t be more aptly named.

Be the first to leave a comment…
Happy SXSW! Enjoy the full Fearless Critic content and advanced search features free for the duration of Austin’s South by Southwest festival, from March 12-22—normally available only to subscribers.

If you enjoy our reviews and would like to keep using Fearless Critic’s online restaurant guide after March 22, we hope you’ll consider supporting independent, ad-free food criticism and becoming a subscriber for just $8 per year—the price of a Mexican martini—or $1.50 per month.

The brand-new Fearless Critic Austin book (paperback, 592 pages, 480 reviews) makes a great accoutrement for your coffee table or dashboard, and it’s also a delightful gift for the foodie in your life. You can get the book at the SXSW vending area, at an Austin-area store, or at Amazon.com.

If you’re already a subscriber, please login to your account. Your subscription has been extended by 10 days for free.